Tax Advice: Protecting Your Confidential Information - Boodle Hatfield

Your lawyers since 1722

Article
19 Nov 2026

Your tax advice is privileged. Don’t give that protection away to an AI chatbot.

Written by

When clients instruct us to advise on a tax question, they are entitled to expect that our advice stays confidential and, if HMRC ever asks to see it, protected by legal professional privilege. That protection is one of the most valuable things a client buys when they instruct a lawyer rather than an adviser who is not legally qualified. It is also surprisingly easy to lose.

We are increasingly seeing clients paste or upload advice notes into public AI platforms such as ChatGPT and Claude, asking for a summary, a plain-English version or a second opinion on whether the advice is right. It is an understandable instinct. It is also, on the current state of the law, one that can put privilege in the advice at serious risk. At the same time, HMRC’s information powers are being modernised in the Finance Bill 2026-27, which makes it more important than ever to know what is, and is not, protected.

Why privilege matters in tax

Legal advice privilege protects confidential communications between a lawyer and client made for the purpose of giving or receiving legal advice. In tax matters, its practical importance is considerable. HMRC’s civil information powers in Schedule 36 to the Finance Act 2008 allow it to require taxpayers, and in defined circumstances third parties, to produce information and documents that are reasonably required to check a tax position.

Those powers are subject to an important limit. Under paragraph 23 of Schedule 36, an information notice does not require a person to provide privileged information or to produce any part of a document that is privileged. Privileged information is defined by reference to whether a claim to legal professional privilege could be maintained in legal proceedings (in Scotland, the equivalent concept is confidentiality of communications between client and professional legal adviser). Paragraph 23(3) also provides for regulations to resolve disputes about privilege, namely the Information Notice: Resolution of Disputes as to Privileged Communications Regulations 2009 (SI 2009/1916). A similar exclusion for privileged information appears in other HMRC regimes, for example section 271 of the Finance Act 2014 in the context of its promoters of tax avoidance schemes provisions.

The contrast with non-lawyer advisers is stark. In R (Prudential plc) v Special Commissioner of Income Tax [2013] UKSC 1, the Supreme Court declined to extend legal advice privilege to advice given by accountants, even where the advice concerned the application of tax law. Paragraphs 24 to 26 of Schedule 36 give limited statutory protection to auditors and tax advisers’ communications, but that protection is narrower than privilege and does not match it. Advice from a solicitor or barrister is therefore in a materially stronger position.

Privilege belongs to the client, not to the adviser. That means the client can lose it and can do so without meaning to.

The new risk: second opinions from AI

Privilege depends on confidentiality. If a client voluntarily shares privileged advice in circumstances that are inconsistent with confidentiality, a claim to privilege may be lost or, at best, become difficult to defend. The typical scenario is simple: a client copies our advice note into a public AI tool and asks it to summarise the advice or to say whether we have got it right.

The courts and regulators have started to speak on the point:

  • The Chancellor of the High Court, in a speech on legal professional privilege in the age of AI on 22 April 2026, observed that confidentiality has always been a prerequisite for privilege and that, on any view, one cannot assume confidentiality is preserved when information is entered into public AI systems.
  • The Upper Tribunal (Immigration and Asylum Chamber), in Munir v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2026] UKUT 81 (IAC), said that putting client correspondence into an open-source AI tool such as ChatGPT places the information in the public domain, and so breaches confidentiality and waives privilege. That statement was made in a professional-conduct context rather than in a dispute about privilege, so it is a strong judicial warning rather than a binding ruling on privilege itself. The tribunal also contrasted open tools with closed-source tools, such as Microsoft Copilot, which do not place information in the public domain.
  • The Solicitors Regulation Authority published a warning notice on 17 August 2026 on the use of AI in legal practice, cautioning that both free and paid systems can pose risks to client confidentiality and that privilege may be lost.
  • In the United States, in United States v Heppner (S.D.N.Y., February 17 2026), Judge Rakoff held that a defendant’s exchanges with Claude were not privileged, in part because Claude is not a lawyer, and that sharing information with an AI provider could amount to waiver. The court noted that the provider’s privacy policy allowed it to collect user inputs and outputs and to disclose them to third parties, including governmental authorities. A US decision does not bind an English court, but the reasoning rests on the same principle: no confidentiality, no privilege.

Two points deserve emphasis. First, the law here is developing and the position will turn on the facts, including the platform, the account type and the terms of use. An enterprise tool operating under contractual confidentiality obligations is a different proposition from a free consumer account. Second, none of that helps a client who does not know which side of the line they are on. Our advice is simple: assume that anything uploaded to a public AI platform is no longer confidential, and that the AI’s own output is not privileged either.

What the Finance Bill does, and what it does not do

There has been considerable press commentary suggesting that HMRC is about to acquire the power to read taxpayers’ AI chat histories. It is worth being precise about what has actually been proposed.

On 13 July 2026, the government published draft legislation reforming HMRC’s civil information and inspection powers under Schedule 36 and updating the computer records provisions in section 114 of the Finance Act 2008. The draft was subject to technical consultation until 7 September 2026, the policy paper was updated on 3 November 2026, and the Budget confirmed the intention to legislate with provisions now contained in clause 231 of Finance Bill 2026-27. The changes are expected to take effect on Royal Assent, which is not anticipated before 2027.

Section 114 is the supporting provision that enables HMRC to access computers used in connection with documents it is entitled to require. The reform is intended to make clear that it covers information held in digital and electronic form, including, in HMRC’s words, information needed to understand how relevant tax figures have been produced, and information held by third-party software providers. HMRC’s own policy paper says that section 114 will continue to operate only as a supporting provision where HMRC already has a lawful basis to require information under Schedule 36, and that the reform does not create a new standalone information power. The draft does not mention AI platforms or chat histories by name.

So, the accurate position is this:

  • The Bill does not, on its face, give HMRC a free-standing right to search personal AI accounts.
  • HMRC must still be exercising a Schedule 36 power, which requires that the information is reasonably required to check a tax position, and notices to third parties generally need the taxpayer’s agreement or tribunal approval.
  • Modernised language on digital records and on how figures were produced could, in an enquiry, make it easier to require material generated or stored in digital systems, and it would be unwise to assume AI-generated tax calculations or related records sit outside that language.
  • Paragraph 23 of Schedule 36 is unchanged by the draft measure as far as we are aware. Privileged material remains outside the scope of a notice.

That last point is where the two threads of this article meet. Privilege is the shield that stands between a client’s advice note and an HMRC information notice. If privilege has been lost because the advice was uploaded to a public platform, the shield may no longer be there. HMRC would still need a valid notice, but the argument that the advice is privileged would be weaker, and the client’s own questions and working assumptions typed into the chatbot, which are rarely written with a future enquiry in mind, may also be in play.

Direction of travel

We do not suggest that HMRC is about to start reading chat logs. But the trend is plain. HMRC issued more than 1,000 financial institution notices in the twelve months to March 2025 and is increasingly willing to use its Schedule 36 powers. The government’s stated aim is to ensure that those powers work effectively in a modern digital tax system. As AI tools become part of how taxpayers handle their affairs, it would not be surprising to see HMRC, and in time Parliament, test how far existing powers reach, or consider whether they need to be extended. We would expect the industry to scrutinise any such proposals closely. In the meantime, clients are best advised to behave as if their AI interactions could one day be examined, because the legal protections are weaker for them than for a conversation with their lawyer.

What clients should do

  1. Do not upload or paste advice from us into a public AI tool. That includes summaries, extracts and screenshots, and includes free and paid consumer accounts.
  2. Ask us instead. If an advice note is unclear, or you want a second view, call us. A conversation with us is privileged; a conversation with a chatbot is not. We can also explain advice in plain English.
  3. Check with us before using any AI tool in relation to your tax affairs. If a firm-approved or enterprise tool with appropriate confidentiality terms is suitable, we can say so.
  4. If you have already uploaded advice, tell us promptly. It may be possible to limit the consequences, and we would rather know now than discover it during an enquiry.
  5. Do not forward our advice to others without speaking to us first, whether other advisers, family members or software providers. Privilege can be lost in any of those ways.
  6. Keep your own records of how tax figures were produced, including those prepared with AI assistance, because HMRC’s focus on how figures are generated is likely to increase.

Conclusion

Privileged tax advice from a lawyer is a valuable, and fragile, protection. The proposed changes to HMRC’s information powers do not remove it, but they come at a time when the careless use of public AI tools is the most likely way for a client to lose it. If you would like to discuss how to use AI safely alongside your advice, or you think you may already have shared advice with an AI platform, we would be happy to advise further.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal or tax advice. The Finance Bill 2026-27 had not been enacted at the date of publication and its final content may differ from the draft clauses.

Written by